The Malvern Hills Trust (MHT) has proposed a Private Bill that has stirred significant controversy among local residents and stakeholders. Here’s a summary of the key concerns and developments:
1. Reduction in Elected Trustees:
The MHT seeks to reduce its board from 29 to 12 trustees, with only six being elected. Critics argue this diminishes democratic representation, especially since residents contribute financially through a levy included in their council tax. The concern is that this change could lead to decisions being made without adequate public oversight.
2. Introduction of a ‘General Power’:
The proposed Bill includes a ‘general power’ clause, allowing the Trust to make decisions without seeking parliamentary approval. Opponents fear this could lead to actions that deviate from the Trust’s original purpose, such as commercializing parts of the Hills or restricting public access.
3. Lack of Transparency and Consultation:
There are allegations that the consultation process was inadequate. Some trustees reportedly did not see the draft Bill before it was submitted to Parliament, raising questions about the legitimacy of the process.
4. Potential for Commercialization:
Residents express concern that the changes could pave the way for commercial ventures on the Hills, compromising their natural beauty and public accessibility. While the Trust denies intentions to commercialize, the inclusion of broad powers in the Bill fuels skepticism.
5. Public Response and Action:
In response to these proposals, local groups like the Malvern Environment Protection Group have mobilized, urging residents to sign petitions and participate in consultations. They emphasize the importance of preserving the Hills’ natural aspect and ensuring that any changes are made transparently and democratically.
Conclusion:
The proposed Private Bill by the Malvern Hills Trust has ignited a debate about governance, transparency, and the future of the Malvern Hills. As the Bill progresses through Parliament, stakeholders continue to advocate for greater public involvement and scrutiny to ensure the Hills remain a cherished public asset.
For more detailed information and to participate in ongoing discussions, please refer to the following resources:
- Geoff Buys Cars: Objections to and Issues with The Malvern Hills Bill
- Malvern Environment Protection Group: Take Action
- BBC News: Locals concerned over future management of Malvern Hills
The Malvern Hills are a striking range of ancient, rugged hills running roughly 13 km (8 miles) north to south. Famous for their sweeping views, natural springs, and dramatic ridgelines, they are designated an Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty (AONB) and have inspired generations of artists, writers, and musicians — including Sir Edward Elgar.
